Farm Insurance NZ :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Insurer Ordered to Cover Restaurant Arson Despite Director's Unrevealed Criminal Record

Insurer Ordered to Cover Restaurant Arson Despite Director's Unrevealed Criminal Record

In a recent decision, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) directed insurer QBE to honour an arson claim for a restaurant, despite the owner's failure to disclose prior criminal convictions during the policy's inception.
The restaurant, which operates from a leased location, suffered extensive damage due to an arson attack on August 2 of last year, halting its business operations.
While the arsonist was apprehended, QBE initially denied the claim, citing non-disclosure of the director's criminal history.

The restaurant's sole director contended the omission was unintentional and emphasised his efforts toward rehabilitation. He proposed to pay any additional premiums necessitated by his past, seeking a fair resolution to his claim. However, QBE maintained that knowledge of his convictions would have impacted their decision to provide coverage from the outset.

AFCA examined the claim documentation, highlighting that QBE had not substantiated its stance. It noted the absence of conclusive evidence of what specific inquiries were made during the policy's initiation, given the broker used an electronic interface linked to QBE's systems. Critically, QBE failed to furnish definitive proof of the questions asked, nor did it provide screenshots of the policy initiation process.

The crux of AFCA's decision rested on the ambiguity of the questions. One inquiry appeared specific to the company's criminal history, rather than its director. Though QBE suggested a duty for directors to disclose past convictions, AFCA's ombudsman determined the insurer did not demonstrate an adequate breach of disclosure obligations by the insured company.

As a result, AFCA concluded that QBE could not justifiably void the policy or deny the claim. The insurer is mandated to reinstate coverage and conduct any additional evaluations required to settle the claim under the policy's terms, all within 28 days of the complainant's acknowledgment of this determination.

This decision underscores the complexities surrounding disclosure obligations in insurance contracts and the critical need for insurers to clearly document and validate their inquiries during the underwriting process.

Published:Thursday, 12th Jun 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

NSW Workers’ Compensation Scheme Faces Major Overhaul Amid Underinsurance Issues NSW Workers’ Compensation Scheme Faces Major Overhaul Amid Underinsurance Issues
23 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The New South Wales State Insurance Regulatory Authority (SIRA) has identified critical issues of underinsurance and employer non-compliance within the icare workers’ compensation scheme. A recent review highlighted that over $60 million in premiums were not collected due to missing wage declarations, with about 75% of employers audited showing non-compliance responsible for an additional $24.5 million in unpaid premiums. - read more
Insurer Prevails in Vehicle Value Dispute Insurer Prevails in Vehicle Value Dispute
23 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

In a recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), a protest from a car owner against her insurer, RAC Insurance, regarding the reduction of her vehicle's agreed value has been dismissed. The case arose after the complainant made a total loss claim following an accident in October, only to discover that her vehicle's value had been adjusted down to $29,700 from a previous total of $40,000. - read more
Microsoft Under Fire After Major SharePoint Security Breach Microsoft Under Fire After Major SharePoint Security Breach
22 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

Microsoft is grappling with an alarming security breach affecting its SharePoint collaboration software, impacting organisations and government entities globally. The Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency (CISA) recently unveiled the vulnerability, warning that it permits unauthorised access to systems and complete access to SharePoint content, enabling malicious actors to execute code across networks. - read more
Insurers Urged to Ensure Fairness Before Stopping Payouts Insurers Urged to Ensure Fairness Before Stopping Payouts
22 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has highlighted the importance of procedural fairness in a ruling against TAL, a major life insurer. The directive stresses that insurers must allow customers an opportunity to respond before ceasing their benefits. This ruling came after TAL halted payments under an income protection policy from May 2023 to February 2024, issuing a procedural fairness letter only in June last year, months after payments ceased. - read more
Tasmanian Liberals Propose State-Backed Insurance Amid Criticism Tasmanian Liberals Propose State-Backed Insurance Amid Criticism
21 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The Tasmanian Liberal Party, under Premier Jeremy Rockliff, is advocating for a state-backed general insurer—TasInsure—should they win the upcoming state election on July 19. This initiative aims to mitigate rising insurance premiums allegedly caused by the national market's failures. However, the plan has been met with strong opposition from private insurers and critics who question its viability. - read more
AFCA Sides with Policyholder in Storm Damage Dispute AFCA Sides with Policyholder in Storm Damage Dispute
18 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

A recent ruling by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) has favoured a policyholder in a dispute with insurer Auto & General over storm damage. The case involved a collapsed ceiling, initially attributed to a storm by the insurer before an about-face led them to deny the claim. The AFCA decision marks a significant instance where consumer protection mechanisms have countered an insurer's attempt to deny coverage. - read more


Farm Insurance Articles

Natural Disaster Preparedness: Insurance Tips for Farmers Facing Adversity Natural Disaster Preparedness: Insurance Tips for Farmers Facing Adversity
In the heart of New Zealand's pastoral verdure, the significance of preparedness for natural disasters is paramount for the farming industry. The distinct landscape, while providing an idyllic backdrop for agricultural pursuits, is not without its challenges. Farmers are often at the mercy of nature's unpredictability, making disaster preparedness not just prudent but essential for the continuity of their livelihood. - read more
Customizing Your Farm Insurance: Tailoring Policies to Fit Unique Agricultural Needs Customizing Your Farm Insurance: Tailoring Policies to Fit Unique Agricultural Needs
Those who work the land know that every farm has its own heartbeat - its unique rhythm defined by the crops it yields, the livestock it nurtures, and the natural environment it exists within. Recognizing this individuality is crucial, especially when it comes to safeguarding your agricultural investment with the right insurance policy. - read more
Protecting Your Farming Future: Why Machinery Breakdown Coverage is Essential Protecting Your Farming Future: Why Machinery Breakdown Coverage is Essential
Farming is a vital part of New Zealand's economy and cultural heritage, representing a way of life for thousands across the country. With its unique landscapes and diverse climate, New Zealand farmers are renowned for producing a wide array of high-quality products that serve not only the nation's needs but also supply a multitude of international markets. - read more
Securing Your Farm's Future: Top Estate Planning Tips for New Zealand Farmers Securing Your Farm's Future: Top Estate Planning Tips for New Zealand Farmers
New Zealand's farming community forms the backbone of its thriving agricultural sector, yet many overlook the critical importance of proactive estate planning. With farmland often being held within families for generations, securing its future is not just a financial concern, but a deeply personal one as well. - read more
Preparing for the Worst: Developing a Comprehensive Disaster Response Plan for Your Farm Preparing for the Worst: Developing a Comprehensive Disaster Response Plan for Your Farm
As a farmer, you know that unexpected events can have a significant impact on your farm and your livelihood. Natural disasters, such as floods, fires, droughts, and storms, can occur at any time and have devastating consequences. That's why it's crucial to have a comprehensive disaster response plan in place to protect your property, assets, and, most importantly, your loved ones and livestock. In this article, we'll provide a step-by-step guide on how to develop a disaster response plan for your farm. - read more
Tractors, Livestock, and Crops: Tailoring Your Farm Insurance to Fit Your Needs Tractors, Livestock, and Crops: Tailoring Your Farm Insurance to Fit Your Needs
Welcome to the world of farming, where the fruits of your labor are as tangible as the soil you till. But just as the land is subject to the whims of nature, so too is the business of agriculture. This is where farm insurance becomes essential. Farmers face a set of challenges and uncertainties unlike any other industry, primarily due to the unpredictable forces of weather. Protecting your agricultural investment with appropriate insurance is not just prudent—it's critical for the survival and prosperity of your farm. - read more
Natural Disaster Preparedness: Insurance Tips for Farmers Facing Adversity Natural Disaster Preparedness: Insurance Tips for Farmers Facing Adversity
In the heart of New Zealand's pastoral verdure, the significance of preparedness for natural disasters is paramount for the farming industry. The distinct landscape, while providing an idyllic backdrop for agricultural pursuits, is not without its challenges. Farmers are often at the mercy of nature's unpredictability, making disaster preparedness not just prudent but essential for the continuity of their livelihood. - read more
Protecting Your Farming Future: Why Machinery Breakdown Coverage is Essential Protecting Your Farming Future: Why Machinery Breakdown Coverage is Essential
Farming is a vital part of New Zealand's economy and cultural heritage, representing a way of life for thousands across the country. With its unique landscapes and diverse climate, New Zealand farmers are renowned for producing a wide array of high-quality products that serve not only the nation's needs but also supply a multitude of international markets. - read more
Customizing Your Farm Insurance: Tailoring Policies to Fit Unique Agricultural Needs Customizing Your Farm Insurance: Tailoring Policies to Fit Unique Agricultural Needs
Those who work the land know that every farm has its own heartbeat - its unique rhythm defined by the crops it yields, the livestock it nurtures, and the natural environment it exists within. Recognizing this individuality is crucial, especially when it comes to safeguarding your agricultural investment with the right insurance policy. - read more

Knowledgebase
Liability Insurance:
Insurance that provides protection from claims arising from injuries or damage to other people or property