Farm Insurance NZ :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Verbal Tenancy Ruling Highlights Evidence Gaps for Landlords

AFCA’s decision favoured a rent-loss claim but rejected poorly supported property theft allegations

Verbal Tenancy Ruling Highlights Evidence Gaps for Landlords?w=400

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

A recent Australian Financial Complaints Authority decision has put a practical spotlight on how landlord insurance claims can turn on both policy wording and the quality of evidence kept during a tenancy.
According to Insurance News reporting on 16 September 2026, AFCA found that a landlord’s verbal periodic tenancy was enough to support a lost-rent claim in the circumstances, even though the insurer argued the policy required a written rental agreement.

The dispute involved a landlord who had taken out optional tenant protection shortly before police carried out an eviction, after a prolonged disagreement with the tenants. The insurer resisted the claim on the basis that there was no written lease. AFCA took a broader view, considering the tenancy law context and the fact that both sides accepted a verbal tenancy existed. It ordered the insurer to accept the lost rent claim, assess parts of the related property damage claim and pay interest from September 2025.

That part of the ruling may reassure landlords who have older or informal tenancy arrangements, but it should not be read as a reason to rely on loose paperwork. AFCA decisions are fact-specific, and another policy, state tenancy setting or evidence trail could produce a different result. The safer lesson is that written agreements, rent ledgers, bond records, notices, inspection reports and correspondence remain important when an insurer needs to establish whether cover applies.

The same decision also shows the limits of a favourable ruling. While the landlord succeeded on the rent-loss issue, AFCA was not satisfied that the alleged theft of furniture had been proved. The reporting noted concerns about inconsistent accounts, a lack of documented inspections, no photographs showing the items at the property, and insufficient evidence of ownership and value. In other words, a landlord can win one part of a claim and still fail on another if the supporting material is weak.

For rental property owners, the practical implications are straightforward:

  • keep tenancy arrangements documented wherever possible, even for periodic tenancies;
  • retain rent records, notices and correspondence in a form that can be retrieved quickly;
  • photograph landlord-owned contents and fixtures during routine inspections;
  • store invoices, serial numbers and replacement values for significant items;
  • check policy wording for tenant protection, rent default, malicious damage and evidence requirements.

The ruling is also a reminder that tenant damage, rent loss and missing property are not the same claim issue. Each may have different triggers, exclusions, limits and proof requirements. Landlords reviewing cover should focus not only on whether a benefit appears in the policy, but on what must be shown if a dispute arises months or years after the tenancy began.

Published:Tuesday, 17th Nov 2026
Author: Paige Estritori

Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.

Share this news item:

Rate this article

0 Comments

No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.

Insurance News

Live Music Insurance Reform Call Has Wider Lessons for Public-Facing Businesses
Live Music Insurance Reform Call Has Wider Lessons for Public-Facing Businesses
18 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
A NSW parliamentary inquiry into the state of live music has put insurance affordability back in the spotlight, with its final report tabled on 9 November 2026 identifying public liability insurance as a major cost burden for venues and festivals. The recommendation does not change premiums immediately, but it gives business owners a useful signal: governments, insurers and industry groups are still grappling with how public-facing risks are priced, documented and managed. - read more
Storm Claims Put Policy Details Under Fresh Pressure
Storm Claims Put Policy Details Under Fresh Pressure
18 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
The Insurance Council of Australia’s expanded Significant Event declaration for severe storms in Queensland and New South Wales is a timely reminder that insurance is tested in the messy aftermath of damage, power loss and disruption, not just at renewal time. By 17 November 2026, insurers had received more than 7,500 claims linked to severe weather from 11 to 17 November, with damage ranging from torn roofs and broken fences to water entry, hail impacts and spoiled food after outages. - read more
Bakery Dispute Shows Supplier Risk Can Interrupt Trade
Bakery Dispute Shows Supplier Risk Can Interrupt Trade
18 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
A recent business interruption dispute involving a bakery has given restaurant and cafe operators a timely reminder that disruption does not always start inside the insured premises. The Australian Financial Complaints Authority found in favour of a bakery retail business after its insurer declined a claim linked to a fire at the premises of its sole supplier, bringing supplier-dependency wording into sharp focus for hospitality businesses that rely on specialist producers, central kitchens, roasters, wholesalers or delivery partners. - read more
Softer Insurance Market Signals Opportunity, Not a Shortcut
Softer Insurance Market Signals Opportunity, Not a Shortcut
17 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
Fresh insurance market reporting points to a more competitive commercial insurance environment across the Pacific region, but personal trainers should be careful not to read headline rate falls as a guarantee that every renewal will become cheaper or simpler. Marsh’s latest Global Insurance Market Index, released in October 2026 for the September quarter, recorded a 12% fall in Pacific commercial insurance rates, marking the eleventh consecutive quarter of decline. - read more
ACCC Review Puts Regional Broker Choice in Focus
ACCC Review Puts Regional Broker Choice in Focus
17 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission’s review of QIB Group Holdings’ proposed acquisition of Queensland-based Axiom Insurance Brokers has put regional insurance broking competition back under the spotlight. The matter is still at an assessment stage, not a finding of concern, but it is a useful reminder that who owns, controls and supports an insurance broker can matter for households, farms and small businesses that rely on local advice and claims assistance. - read more
Underpaid Claims Put Life Insurer Controls in Focus
Underpaid Claims Put Life Insurer Controls in Focus
17 Nov 2026: Paige Estritori
A fresh Life Code Compliance Committee sanction has put claim payment accuracy back in focus after an unnamed life insurer underpaid about $1.6 million, including interest, across 66 income protection and death benefit claims. The 16 November 2026 case is de-identified, but its message is clear: life insurance obligations do not end when a claim is accepted; customers also need the right benefit calculated, explained and paid. - read more


Farm Insurance Articles

Livestock and Crop Insurance in New Zealand: What Farmers Should Understand
Livestock and Crop Insurance in New Zealand: What Farmers Should Understand
Livestock and crops are among the most important assets on many New Zealand farms. This guide explains how livestock and crop insurance can fit into a broader farm insurance policy, what risks may be considered, and what records farmers may need when reviewing cover. - read more
What Affects the Cost of Farm Insurance in New Zealand?
What Affects the Cost of Farm Insurance in New Zealand?
Farm insurance premiums in New Zealand can vary widely because each farm has different assets, activities, exposures and cover choices. This guide explains the main factors that may influence the cost of a rural insurance quote. - read more
Natural Disaster Preparedness: Insurance Tips for Farmers Facing Adversity
Natural Disaster Preparedness: Insurance Tips for Farmers Facing Adversity
In the heart of New Zealand's pastoral verdure, the significance of preparedness for natural disasters is paramount for the farming industry. The distinct landscape, while providing an idyllic backdrop for agricultural pursuits, is not without its challenges. Farmers are often at the mercy of nature's unpredictability, making disaster preparedness not just prudent but essential for the continuity of their livelihood. - read more
Securing Your Farm's Future: Top Estate Planning Tips for New Zealand Farmers
Securing Your Farm's Future: Top Estate Planning Tips for New Zealand Farmers
New Zealand's farming community forms the backbone of its thriving agricultural sector, yet many overlook the critical importance of proactive estate planning. With farmland often being held within families for generations, securing its future is not just a financial concern, but a deeply personal one as well. - read more
What Can Farm Insurance Cover in New Zealand?
What Can Farm Insurance Cover in New Zealand?
Farm insurance in New Zealand can combine cover for buildings, machinery, vehicles, livestock, crops, liability, income disruption and other rural risks, depending on the policy and farm operation. - read more
Customizing Your Farm Insurance: Tailoring Policies to Fit Unique Agricultural Needs
Customizing Your Farm Insurance: Tailoring Policies to Fit Unique Agricultural Needs
Those who work the land know that every farm has its own heartbeat - its unique rhythm defined by the crops it yields, the livestock it nurtures, and the natural environment it exists within. Recognizing this individuality is crucial, especially when it comes to safeguarding your agricultural investment with the right insurance policy. - read more

Need a Quote?
Start your free farm insurance quote comparison here.

Start here

Farm Type:
Postcode:

Knowledgebase
Professional indemnity:
An insurance that provides cover for liability incurred in the course of exercising a profession.