Unsecure Vehicle Leads to Rejected Insurance Claim

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

According to a ruling from the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), Auto & General Services rejected the claim on the grounds that the owner left the car unlocked and unattended with keys inside. This incident underscores the importance of basic security measures in protecting one's assets.

The car owner had parked at his parents’ home for a morning visit. Despite conceding the car was left unlocked with the keys, he contested that it wasn't unattended. He explained that he, along with friends and family, had a view of the vehicle from inside the house where they were watching a basketball game. Additionally, he argued that his sister-in-law was outside near the vehicle’s parking spot.

Contrary to these claims, the insurer pointed out that it took more than 45 minutes for the theft to be noticed. They also found that the sister-in-law was not present in the garden when the theft occurred. The AFCA sided with the insurer, stating that the individuals inside were "not looking at, or paying attention to, what was happening outside, but rather were watching basketball and chatting."

AFCA emphasized that the insurance policy specifically required the vehicle not to be left unsecured and unattended "for any time period." This condition was breached, they noted, since reasonable efforts to safeguard the car were not taken.

The complainant further argued that with modern technology, the car could have been stolen even without the keys inside. However, the authority rebutted, indicating that the vehicle became "an easier target for theft than one which is secured." An AFCA ombudsman observed, “I am satisfied that leaving the key in the car while unattended can reasonably be regarded as being capable of causing or contributing to the theft.”

This case sheds light on the essential, yet often overlooked, practice of securing one's vehicle at all times. While sophisticated methods to steal vehicles do exist, minimum precautions like locking and removing keys make a significant difference in deterring theft. By neglecting these steps, car owners increase the risk their vehicles could be an attractive target for opportunistic thieves.

The original report from Insurance News conveys the message that car insurance policies obligate policyholders to actively secure their vehicles. This ensures that in the unfortunate event of theft, insurance protection is not compromised by preventable lapses.

Published:Thursday, 31st Oct 2024
Author: Paige Estritori

Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Why Firmer Cattle Prices Should Trigger an Insurance Check

15 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Recent rural market reporting has pointed to firmer cattle values across parts of eastern Australia, with improved seasonal confidence, restocker demand and tighter supply helping support prices in a number of saleyards. For producers, stronger prices are welcome after a period of difficult seasonal and cost pressures. But there is also a quieter insurance issue sitting behind the market lift: if livestock values rise, the financial exposure carried by the farm may rise with them. - read more

Softer premiums do not remove the need for sharper cover checks

15 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Recent commercial insurance market commentary points to a more favourable pricing environment for many Australian business buyers, with competition returning in some lines after several years of tougher renewal conditions. For consultants, this is welcome news, but it should not be mistaken for a signal that professional risk has become simple or low-cost to insure. - read more

Why Cyber Insurance Reviews Are Becoming More Urgent

15 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Cyber insurance has moved from a specialist add-on to a mainstream business risk issue. Recent industry commentary points to a more selective market: insurers are examining security controls, data handling and outsourced technology dependencies before offering terms. For many Australian small businesses, that means a renewal is no longer just a price conversation. It is a test of whether the business can show how it prevents, detects and recovers from an incident. - read more

Affordability Pressure Is Changing the Risk Picture for Landlords

15 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Recent rental market commentary is again highlighting a practical issue for Australian landlords: tenant affordability is becoming a stronger force in how rental demand behaves. While many areas remain tight by historical standards, rising living costs and stretched household budgets are changing what renters can absorb, where they look, and how long they stay. - read more

What Electric Heavy Vehicles Mean for Truck Insurance

10 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

Recent transport and fleet industry coverage continues to point to a steady increase in electric and low-emission heavy vehicles across Australian logistics operations. For many operators, the attraction is clear: quieter vehicles, lower tailpipe emissions, potential fuel savings and stronger alignment with customer sustainability targets. But the insurance conversation is now becoming more detailed than simply replacing a diesel truck with an electric one. - read more

Why the Latest Insurance Data Matters for Trade Businesses

10 Sep 2026: Paige Estritori

APRA’s latest quarterly general insurance statistics point to a market that is still under cost pressure, even as insurers continue to report stronger overall results than during the worst of the recent claims cycle. For Australian tradespeople, the headline is not simply whether insurers are profitable. The practical issue is how rising premiums, repair costs, reinsurance expenses and claims activity flow through to the price and availability of cover used every day on the tools. - read more

Click for more Insurance News