Unsecure Vehicle Leads to Rejected Insurance Claim
Unsecure Vehicle Leads to Rejected Insurance Claim
The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.
In a cautionary tale for vehicle owners, a policyholder's failure to secure their car against theft resulted in a denied insurance claim after the vehicle was stolen during a family event.
According to a ruling from the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), Auto & General Services rejected the claim on the grounds that the owner left the car unlocked and unattended with keys inside. This incident underscores the importance of basic security measures in protecting one's assets.
The car owner had parked at his parents’ home for a morning visit. Despite conceding the car was left unlocked with the keys, he contested that it wasn't unattended. He explained that he, along with friends and family, had a view of the vehicle from inside the house where they were watching a basketball game. Additionally, he argued that his sister-in-law was outside near the vehicle’s parking spot.
Contrary to these claims, the insurer pointed out that it took more than 45 minutes for the theft to be noticed. They also found that the sister-in-law was not present in the garden when the theft occurred. The AFCA sided with the insurer, stating that the individuals inside were "not looking at, or paying attention to, what was happening outside, but rather were watching basketball and chatting."
AFCA emphasized that the insurance policy specifically required the vehicle not to be left unsecured and unattended "for any time period." This condition was breached, they noted, since reasonable efforts to safeguard the car were not taken.
The complainant further argued that with modern technology, the car could have been stolen even without the keys inside. However, the authority rebutted, indicating that the vehicle became "an easier target for theft than one which is secured." An AFCA ombudsman observed, “I am satisfied that leaving the key in the car while unattended can reasonably be regarded as being capable of causing or contributing to the theft.”
This case sheds light on the essential, yet often overlooked, practice of securing one's vehicle at all times. While sophisticated methods to steal vehicles do exist, minimum precautions like locking and removing keys make a significant difference in deterring theft. By neglecting these steps, car owners increase the risk their vehicles could be an attractive target for opportunistic thieves.
The original report from Insurance News conveys the message that car insurance policies obligate policyholders to actively secure their vehicles. This ensures that in the unfortunate event of theft, insurance protection is not compromised by preventable lapses.
Please Note: We do not endorse any specific products or companies. Some content is sourced from third parties, including press releases, and may not be independently verified for accuracy or completeness.
Australia’s latest bushfire loss update offers a practical warning for restaurant, café and hospitality operators: natural catastrophe risk is not confined to homes, farms or large industrial sites. Perils has lifted its estimate for the January 2026 Victorian bushfires to $860 million, with commercial properties accounting for the largest share of insured losses. - read more
QBE and Blue Zebra have extended their motor underwriting partnership, with Blue Zebra confirming a new multi-year agreement after the previous arrangement expired. QBE has been underwriting Blue Zebra’s commercial and private motor products since July last year, following the end of the agency’s earlier arrangement with Youi. - read more
A new Australian Financial Complaints Authority decision has put income protection claims under the spotlight, with useful lessons for tradies who rely on their own capacity to work. The dispute involved a delivery driver who had received weekly income protection benefits after a serious arm-related medical condition prevented him from working. The insurer later tried to recover more than $31,000 in paid benefits, arguing it had information suggesting he could have returned to work earlier. - read more
CHU Underwriting Agencies has launched its inaugural Green Grant Program, distributing $50,000 across seven strata communities on 16 July 2026. The initiative is modest in scale, with grants capped at $10,000 per successful application, but it points to a larger change in the way strata insurance risk is being discussed. Instead of focusing only on premium increases after extreme weather or building losses, insurers are increasingly looking at practical ways to reduce risk before claims occur. - read more
Marsh Risk has appointed Justin Gillingham as its new head of strata, in a move that reflects how quickly the Australian strata insurance market is becoming more specialised. Announced on 20 July 2026, the appointment brings a senior insurance and risk professional into a role focused on buildings, owners corporations and communities dealing with increasingly complicated cover, compliance and claims issues. - read more
A new industry estimate has put the insured cost of Victoria’s January bushfires at $860 million, sharpening the focus on how quickly natural disaster losses can affect businesses that rely on vehicles, tools, workshops, stock and regional worksites. For tradies, the important detail is not just the size of the loss, but where it landed: commercial property reportedly accounted for the largest share, ahead of personal property and motor losses. - read more
In the heart of New Zealand's pastoral verdure, the significance of preparedness for natural disasters is paramount for the farming industry. The distinct landscape, while providing an idyllic backdrop for agricultural pursuits, is not without its challenges. Farmers are often at the mercy of nature's unpredictability, making disaster preparedness not just prudent but essential for the continuity of their livelihood. - read more
Farming is a vital part of New Zealand's economy and cultural heritage, representing a way of life for thousands across the country. With its unique landscapes and diverse climate, New Zealand farmers are renowned for producing a wide array of high-quality products that serve not only the nation's needs but also supply a multitude of international markets. - read more
Those who work the land know that every farm has its own heartbeat - its unique rhythm defined by the crops it yields, the livestock it nurtures, and the natural environment it exists within. Recognizing this individuality is crucial, especially when it comes to safeguarding your agricultural investment with the right insurance policy. - read more
New Zealand's farming community forms the backbone of its thriving agricultural sector, yet many overlook the critical importance of proactive estate planning. With farmland often being held within families for generations, securing its future is not just a financial concern, but a deeply personal one as well. - read more
Need a Quote?
Start your free farm insurance quote comparison here.
Knowledgebase
Loss of Use: Insurance coverage that pays for the additional living expenses if your home is uninhabitable due to a covered loss.
No comments yet. Be the first to share your thoughts.